| Indianapolis |
| Passing: | Peyton Manning 14/16 (95 YDS) |
| Rushing: | Joseph Addai 4 CAR (27 YDS) |
| Receiving: | Reggie Wayne 12 REC (87 YDS) |
|
| Tennessee |
| Passing: | Vince Young 14/18 (157 YDS) |
| Rushing: | LenDale White 16 CAR (45 YDS) |
| Receiving: | Justin Gage 7 REC (104 YDS) |